Fresh curiosities ♥ grading notes, odd finds, and shop stories ♥ Join the list free →

Online thrift finds shipped from Wisconsin

We don't specialize in one thing—we specialize in finding great things. Every day new discoveries arrive, from comics and trading cards to apparel, media, collectibles, and everything in between.

Browse Finds
Real photos, every item
Honest condition notes
New finds weekly

Handled with care

Good finds, handled with care.

Every discovery gets real photos, clear notes, and careful Wisconsin handling. The fun stays in the find, not in wondering what shows up.

What keeps it clear

Found things. Carefully described.

TBM is built around the joy of finding the good stuff: comics, cards, apparel, media, collectibles, and the odd little pieces that deserve a second look.

  • Real photosThe item in the listing is the item that shows up at your door.
  • Careful handlingEverything moves from our Wisconsin setup with the same steady, careful process.
  • Honest notesIf there is a flaw, we call it out instead of hoping nobody notices.
Browse Finds Read the Journal

Browse the trove

New curiosities every week.

Comics, trading cards, apparel, media, collectibles, and everything in between — fresh discoveries added as they arrive.

Apparel category cardApparel Shoes category cardShoes & accessories Hats category cardHats Media category cardMedia Collectibles category cardCollectibles Trading cards category cardTrading cards

Why it feels easy

A softer way to browse the trove.

Thrift By Mail keeps the thrill of secondhand shopping, then slows the details down: real photos, calm notes, and careful in-house review.

Made for return visits that feel good.

The discoveries keep changing, but the standards stay familiar. That means clearer listings, steadier condition notes, and fewer surprises when something catches your eye.

  • Real photos — the piece you fall for is the piece that shows up.
  • Honest notes — flaws, wear, measurements, and odd little details get called out plainly.
  • Steady handling — each find is checked, described, and packed with the same care.

From the journal

Notes from the trove. A little more of the story.

Field notes on good finds, careful descriptions, curious categories, and the small details that make secondhand shopping feel warmer.

Fresh notes

Little stories, better find notes.

The journal holds the longer version: what came in, what made us pause, how we checked it, and what felt worth passing along.

  • Fresh arrivalsNew discoveries, odd corners of the trove, and the kinds of pieces that deserve a second look.
  • Careful detailsSimple notes on condition, value, and the small specifics that help a listing feel clear.
  • Workbench storiesHow TBM sources, reviews, and writes up each find before it heads out.
Read the Journal How we grade
FAQ

Common curiosities.

The quick answers on shipping, condition notes, authenticity, and how the trove keeps moving.

Everything is inspected, documented, and handled right from our Wisconsin setup with the same steady in-house standards before it ships out. Depending on where you shopped, your order goes out directly from our listings on eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, or Depop.
All purchases are completed through the specific marketplace where you bought the item. For eBay, eBay's buyer protection and return windows apply. For Poshmark, Mercari, and Depop, their respective platform policies, protection rules, and return windows govern the transaction. Check the specific listing for exact terms, and message us directly on the platform where you purchased if anything seems off.
We do our best to weed out fakes, bad reproductions, and anything that does not meet our standards before it ever gets listed. We inspect vintage, designer, and collectible items carefully, note flaws clearly, and use a consistent review process to keep the catalog authentic and clean.
It has to spark a little curiosity, have enough personality to stand out, and come with clear enough notes that you feel completely confident bringing it home.
New discoveries and fresh curiosities land in the trove every single week, so there is always something new waiting to be found.
Still curious about something?

The journal has buying notes, condition details, and a little more of the story behind the trove.

Read the Journal